Sign Up for Cat Talk
Get the latest health and behavior news and
advice from the veterinarians at Tufts University.

Feature October 2018 Issue

Which Nutrition Websites to Trust

Here are eight questions to ask before relying on information found on a pet nutrition website and the sites that we find to be the most reliable.

@ Drazen_/Getty Images

It can be tempting to believe certain things you come across on the Internet, but understanding the source of the information is critically important.

When you do an Internet search on “how to feed a cat with cancer” and come upon a website that says to buy your pet a supplement designed by the person running the site, your instinct to feel suspicious kicks in automatically. Or when you click on a website that says not to feed your cat a diet with grains because cats are not naturally grain eaters, and the site points out that you don’t see cats grazing in grassy fields. (For the record, cats tolerate grains just fine.)

So how do you pick a reputable site for learning more about cat nutrition and what to think about when feeding your pet, separating the hype or quackery from tried-and-true scientifically backed information? After all, even though it has been only about 25 years since searching the Internet for information has even been a thing, there are now literally thousands of websites pertaining to pet nutrition, happy to tell you what to feed your pet, what foods will “cure” him, what ingredients to avoid — even get-rich schemes beckoning you to get in on selling nutrition supplements.

When assessing a website, you should ask yourself the following eight questions. They will go a long way in helping you determine whether the information provided is legitimate. Considering these questions will help you figure out not just the legitimacy of nutrition websites for cats but the legitimacy of websites devoted to feline health and behavior in general. They’ll even help you ascertain the validity of information contained in websites about health for people.

For those who want a cheat sheet on some of the best websites out there for cat nutrition, take a look at page 5 for the list we compiled for you.

The eight questions to ask

(1) Who authored the information? The name of the game here is credentials. Is the person providing the information or advice a fellow pet owner or someone who “invented” something that she or he is now selling? Or is it a veterinarian, someone with a PhD in animal nutrition or a board-certified veterinary nutritionist? A “pet nutritionist” or a “certified nutritionist” is not enough.

Those terms have no legal meaning, as there is no standard training for either of those titles. In fact, you can hang out a shingle calling yourself a “veterinary nutritionist” even if you know nothing about cat food and still not run afoul of the law.

Only veterinarians who have been board-certified by the American College of Veterinary Nutrition (ACVN) or the European College of Veterinary Comparative Nutrition (ECVCN) are guaranteed to have undergone several years of rigorous training in approved residency programs after they have already graduated from veterinary school and also to have passed a certifying examination.

(2) What is the end of the website address after the “dot?” A website ending in .edu is a good bet; it means the source is an educational institution. If it’s a veterinary school, so much the better. Websites that end in .org are operated by non-profit organizations. That lends a degree of credibility because they do not have a vested interest; if they recom-mend a food or other nutrition product, it’s not because they will make money off the sale. But that doesn’t guarantee the information is accurate or scientifically based.

Websites that end in .com do have commercial interests, which should raise a red flag. But just as not all .orgs are reliable sources of information, not all .coms should automatically be written off, either. Large pet food manufacturers have sites that end in .com and often provide excellent nutrition information because they have board-certified veterinary nutritionists and/or PhDs in animal nutrition on staff.

(3) Does the site “prescribe” a particular diet or list ingredients that should be included — or avoided — in a cat’s diet? Approach such sites with a healthy dose of skepticism. There is no single diet that can be prescribed for all cats, nor is there a legitimate list of “good” and “bad” ingredients, unless you’re talking about toxic substances listed by a reputable organization like the ASPCA. If you read about foods that can “cure” or “ward off” illness like cancer or heart disease as well as foods cats should “never” eat, something’s probably wrong.

Ditto for “miracle” foods or supplements. No single food or food ingredient is a miracle. At best, it might be part of a healthful diet that contributes to improved health.

(4) Is the “proof” on the website anecdotal? Testimonials from cat owners that a particular diet or food “did the trick” and made a pet all better — or much worse — should render your suspicion level red hot. Testimonials don’t count as evidence. Only conclusions reached by the scientific community through the course of rigorously conducted research that has been published in peer-reviewed journals do. No matter how convincing a testimonial sounds, it is not proof of anything. For instance, a cat who suddenly is free of arthritis symptoms after eating a particular food or ingredient might simply be experiencing a lessening of symptoms that comes with the ebb and flow of the disease. Treat anecdotes about a product’s efficacy like fairy tales.

(5) Does the science validate the advice? This one is tricky. A lot of websites reference well-conducted studies that have undergone peer review and have been published in respected scientific journals. But some of those sites use the study results to justify specific dietary advice for cats when those results do not pave the way for such advice.

Consider, first of all, that one study does not a fact make. It takes a number of studies conducted by different people in the field, with results generally leading in the same direction, for the scientific community at large to conclude that the evidence is firm enough to use for making dietary recommendations.

Second, some sites list legitimate studies for the purpose of pushing their point of view, or the product they want to sell, rather than because those studies truly suggest the direction a cat’s diet should take.

If the evidence on a site is presented in such a way that you’re finding it hard to understand, that’s not a good sign. Trustworthy sites that make use of scientific information to inform the public take pains to explain the research in such a way that people will have an easy time understanding why the science supports the actual dietary advice.

(6) How timely is the information? Things change quickly in the pet nutrition world. Even the calories and other nutrients in commercial pet foods change on a relatively fre-quent basis. Advice based on medical advances changes, too. What was legitimately recommended as recently as two years ago may not be the gold standard today. Be certain the website you’re perusing is updated frequently.

(7) Are the pet foods discussed ranked? Don’t put stock in websites that rate cat foods. Rankings of pet foods are most often based on opinion or criteria such as price, neither of which has anything to do with the true quality of the food. Besides, the best pet food for one cat might not be the best for another, depending on differences in their health status. To consider whether to feed a commercially prepared food to your cat, your best bet is to choose one from a large, reputable company that has been in business for many years.

(8) Does it sound too good to be true? Things sound too good to be true for a reason — they’re not true. A certain spice cannot “cure” or ward off cancer; a certain dietary regimen cannot take care of heart disease; a particular supplement cannot suddenly stop an itchy cat from scratching. If they could, the scientific community at large would be happy to shout such findings from the rooftop.

True researchers are not looking to keep advances in nutrition medicine from you, and you did not happen to come upon a huge “secret” that the website is sharing with you because the veterinary community will not. If a nutrition claim is made that has not been confirmed anywhere else, move on. — Larry Lindner

Comments (4)

At the top of this article, there's a blue box, right below the Story Tools box, that says "Nutrition Websites-the Best of the Best". Just click on that.

Posted by: Kitsit | October 2, 2018 3:31 AM    Report this comment

There's a blue box at the top of the first page that says "Nutrition Websites-the Best of the Best". It's just below the box that says "Story Tools".

Posted by: Kitsit | October 2, 2018 3:29 AM    Report this comment

I also did not find page 5.

My cat has CKD, and one very comprehensive website that meets the criteria in this month's article is Tanya's Comprehensive Guide to Feline Chronic Kidney Disease, maintained by Helen Fitzsimons. It includes a list of canned foods, ranked by phosphorus and other content, using dry matter analysis data.

George C. (Calypso's servant), Albany NY

Posted by: Catnip Reader | October 1, 2018 12:42 PM    Report this comment

How do I find Page 5 for the list???

Posted by: missannienow | October 1, 2018 10:00 AM    Report this comment

New to Tufts Catnip? Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In